Writing, Spirituality, and Social Justice

When I first became serious about my commitment to social justice and to spiritual growth, I had difficulty determining whether or how the two connected. I felt as if I were on two parallel but unconnected paths. It was through reading and writing, my first loves, that the connections became clear. I will explore these connections in this blog, drawing on my own experiences and work by other writers.

Name: Argie
Location: Minnesota, United States

I am a mother to a teenage girl adopted out of foster care. I teach and coordinate the service-learning program at a small, liberal arts college in a small town. I am a reader, writer, spiritual seeker, and activist--and this blog is about bringing all of these identities together and making sense of them, day by day.

Sunday, November 30, 2008

Holidays and Horses

This weekend, S. and I offered to help care for the seven horses that live in the campus' barn (as well as two cats living temporarily alone on opposite ends of town, but I digress). I don't know the first thing about taking care of horses, but S. has learned a lot in her eight months of lessons, and she knows each of the horses well. (Even after four days of seeing them twice each day for about an hour, I have yet to tell a couple of them apart--this either proves I'm not very observant or not a horse person, or both). Usually there are seven students, or more, taking care of these horses, but only two students were sticking around, so our help was welcomed.

I'll just admit this: I agreed to do this partly because I was hoping to convince S. that she's not ready for her own horse, which she desperately wants and hopes I will decide to purchase for her for her 16th birthday. "I want a horse, not horsepower, for my sweet 16," she keeps saying. I keep telling her I'm not sure either car or horse is possible financially, though the horse, if we were to keep him/her on campus (something S's horse teacher was sure to point out was possible for a faculty member), would actually be cheaper and, I think, a better investment in S's future, since she wants to do something with animals as a career.

Still, I thought if she had to be at the barn at 8:00 every morning to feed the horses, lead them out the pasture, and muck their stalls--and again at 7:30 every night to lead them in and feed them--well, this was going to get old, and she'd realize that she's not really ready, yet, for this kind of responsibility. Did I mention we live in a place where late November is very, very cold? I was willing to suffer through it because, like I said, I had an ulterior motive.

But things did not go exactly as planned. S. got up willingly, even excitedly, every morning--to say that this does not generally occur on school days would be an understatement. And, in all of the time we spent with the horses, there were only two ten-minute intervals during which she was not helpful--one morning, she dazed out for awhile and worked on combing out a horse's tail (rather than mucking her stall), and one evening, she lost her glove and became fixated on finding it rather than helping with leading the horses back into the barn (thankfully, one of the two students helped her). But in both cases, she was able immediately to reflect on what had happened: "I know I need to be more focused if I really want my own horse, mom."

Oh, yes: she's a smart kid, and she knew this was a test. But, honestly, aside from these two incidents, she was truly helpful. Sometimes she needed to have a reminder about the next task, but she completed each task willingly and much more skillfully than I did.

But that's not really the point of the story. Something strange happened in the mornings and evenings we worked with the horses, something almost miraculous. We noticed the sunrise. We noticed the geese. ("You need to write a poem about that, mom, because the way they move through the sky is so beautiful--just look."). We noticed that we actually liked the smell of horses ("I'd rather smell this in the morning than anything else--no offense to your cooking, mom."). Sometimes I got irritated and barked out orders; sometimes she got irritated and corrected my inept attempts to be helpful--but neither of us seemed to mind very much. We were able, on the drive back home, to let go of whatever had happened and talk instead about the things we were realizing about each horse--like people, they have their own quirks, their own personalities.

There's also something satisfying--and this I already knew about myself--about physical labor that is repeated over and over again, each day. During my sophomore year of college, which was a particularly difficult year for me, I think I was saved by the physical labor involved in working the opening shift at one of the campus cafeterias. My job involved getting up at an ungodly hour to vacuum the space, then cleaning the restrooms (that part was kind of gross), then cutting the vegetables for all the sandwiches that day. I found myself, in those quiet, early morning shifts, singing or praying or talking to the dead ancestors who were always hovering close. I found myself noticing the smallest things on my walk to and from my dorm room. I made big decisions ("Of course I'll drop that class; of course I'll change my major; of course I don't feel about him the way he feels about me, and I think this maybe means not only that I'm not supposed to date him, but that I'm not supposed to date boys; of course I need to move out even if it ruins my friendship because I'm miserable"--etc).

On the days that I worked, I was less impatient with my roommate, my friends, and more able to concentrate on my schoolwork, less depressed. I also noticed things I wouldn't have otherwise noticed about how each day differed from the one before: why was there no toilet paper in the first stall today, when usually there is? Why did these tomatoes appear to be so much stiffer than the last batch? I would make up creative answers to these questions that sometimes led to stories or poems. Physical labor forces the mind to slow down, and open up, at the same time.

I am not depressed these days, thankfully, nor am I feeling unsure about the next steps in my life. But things have been rather hectic in the last month for a multitude of reasons--no need to go further with that, just take my word for it--so I haven't felt very settled or calm. So it was good to feel my mind slowing down, feel the prayers--and, later, with them, the poems and stories--begin to move in my body.

"I'm going to miss the horses," S. said to me this morning, after our last shift. "I know if I got my own horse it would be my responsibility, mom, but you have to admit, you sort of like it, too. Plus, it's nice for us to share this."

OK...so maybe she is/we are almost ready for our own horse. All of my earlier objections--the time, the cost, the fact that it would be harder to get away--all of them seemed completely and strangely ridiculous when I followed my daughter on Thanksgiving morning out to the pasture. She was whispering secrets to the horse she was leading, whose ears were cocked toward her. Her stride matched the horse's exactly, and when some geese flew overhead, she whispered "Ho" and the horse stopped immediately and appeared to look up with her. After a couple minutes, she said, "Walk on," and then said, ("See, Mom, that's how you do it. If you want to stop, you say ho. If she stops on you when you don't want her to, just swing the lead rope a little and tell her to walk on."). She was standing so straight, her head up, and there was no frustration or grief in her voice, just a calm confidence.

---

On Thanksgiving morning, after the horses, and this morning, too, S. and I did a spiritual ritual. We sang songs together (neither of us has a very good singing voice) about gratitude and grace, lit candles for all the things we were thankful for. In reciting this list, we told the story of our time together: how lucky to have found each other, how lucky we didn't give up, how lucky we have so many people and animals in our lives who keep us afloat and sane and, yes, joyful. We chose some readings from the Unitarian Universalist hymnal and sat on the couch, reading them out loud together. It feels like we are getting the spiritual thing right, finally--this is something we can do together no matter where we each are on our spiritual journey, whether or not S. ends up believing in God.

---

For my first several years here, I'd had Thanksgiving always with the same friends, but since they left town, each year has been different. Last year there was a giant feast with more than 30 adults and some 10 children, and I'd made a lot of the food. At that time, I was talking to S. on the phone, and we were trying to decide if we wanted to meet, and I distinctly remember my friend C. saying to me, "Is it strange to think that by this time next year you might have your own kid?" I couldn't let myself believe it, but I did feel somehow like things were never going to be the same again.

This year, most of those friends have either moved away or were out of town, so we ate with the other Greek family in town, whom S. loves mainly because they are horse people--though of course, by now, there are other, better reasons, too. She didn't know the 20-something kids who came back with significant others, or the elderly mother of my Greek friend's husband, but she was at ease, and there was a reprieve between courses that involved a trip to the barn where there horse now stays. I felt so grateful to have been included.

I didn't have to do much cooking; I made a few vegetarian dishes, but doing so felt easy, low-stress. I found myself, both while making the dishes and caring for the horses, doing what I used to do when I cut vegetables every morning so many years ago: talking to the dead, praying for the living, feeling the pieces of my life fall into to place.

As I peeled potatoes and yams, I offered up prayers for the people who would eat the food, and then, moving out from that circle, for all the people who had ever shared Thanksgiving with me. I remembered how, the first year after my separation from my partner, a small family of new friends had invited me, how I'd cried that morning while making the one appetizer I had to make, but how, in the end, it had turned out so beautifully, a small and quiet gathering for which I was truly grateful. I offered up prayers for the friends who had always hosted my partner and I before that, and, before that, the haphazard group of graduate students who gathered each year in Phoenix. And, of course, I prayed for my family, though at this point, it's been more than 15 years since I spent a Thanksgiving with them. And then I came back to the present, all of the people who have made an impact on S. and me in our first year together. I felt the old warmth in my body that I used to feel when praying and realized I hadn't felt it in awhile.

These prayers and thoughts went on as I mucked stalls, led the horses in and out of the pasture. They went on as S. and cleaned house, prepared for the incoming gigantic and fragrant tree and dragged said tree through our very narrow doorway. They became the words I used to explain the history of each ornament we unwrapped together. They went on as I wrote--a lot--this weekend, returning to old material, writing some new poems. They became the writing, and the poems, and the memories S. and I were making together. They spilled into the new, private family rituals S. excitedly created for the holidays, insisting that we need to make our own "new traditions," and I happily agreed.

Tonight, S. said, "Isn't it weird how we were just going along all those years, living our lives, and we didn't even know about each other?" She sighed. "And now you're my mother. You didn't give up on me. Sometimes I can hardly believe it."

"I know what you mean," I said, and I did, not just intellectually, but in the deepest parts of my body. And I let myself feel that all-over-gratitude, that strange feeling of everything being exactly as it should be. Usually this feeling is accompanied by either a dull panic ("This can't go on forever") or a low-grade grief ("This can't go on forever"), but for the first time in I think my entire life, I let go of all the what ifs--what if I lose my job in the next round of budget cuts, what if S. begins to regress, what if she can't figure out what to do when she turns 18, what if I can't really afford a horse and I'm dreaming, what if...

I let each of those worries go through my mind and I felt myself observing them, as if from a distance. Superimposed over them were the images of the weekend: when we turned out the lights and sat in silence in front of the tree, in awe at its beauty; when we walked to the lake and watched the geese taking off, black-ribbon-streams lifting and unfurling, finding their shape; when S. took off the last horse's halter that Thanksgiving morning and whispered "Go on, go out to the pasture with your friends, we'll be back tonight again."

This feeling doesn't have to be fleeting, or momentary, I realized. There are always going to be disasters looming, things going wrong. There will always be a dying friend or a social injustice or a war--and our job is, of course, to pay attention, to do what we can, but perhaps our job is also to know how to do the ordinary tasks of our lives, and then, to stand still in the midst of it all, to maintain the feeling of deep gratitude, to stay open, to fight paralysis and bitterness by paying close attention.

"It's like the secret to happiness has been here all along but I didn't see it," I said out loud, accidentally.

"That's right, Mom," S. replied. "Cody, Pennie, Snowbee (our dog and cats) and I have been your secret to happiness all along. It just took you 37 years to find it. But you'd be even happier if we also had a horse, admit it."

OK, I'll admit it--but not out loud, not quite yet!

Tuesday, November 18, 2008

storming/quiet

One day the weather is blue and warm, the dog bounding excitedly out the door, and the next, snowy-bright-white, easy-packing snow, the dog cautious, watchful. Soon after all is melted again and the snowperson's head has fallen off, a small, white ball among the unracked leaves.

One day the house is full of people I truly love who are celebrating or mourning, candles lit, an abundance of food; the next, my daughter is kicking me, twisting my arm, her most violent outburst so far.

And then we're standing on the roadside and she's holding a sign that says "I love my lesbian mom," and then there's another gathering that turns ugly toward the end and I'm wondering why I didn't step in when two friends got into an argument, knowing the hurt that could happen, kicking myself for pulling away. And then I'm screaming at my daughter louder than I ever have and she's crying, I don't remember why--too many refusals in a row to do what I've asked, to even consider the reasons for the asking, and immediately I'm guilty and sorry and so is she.

And then we're building a snowperson and she insists it's my friend T, who "will be here forever because she's strong-willed," and I'm surprised she's said such wise words about someone she doesn't know well who is, yes, strong-willed, solid, as S. says, "The way I want to be."

One last image: my daughter and I are at our first ballet lesson; she's graceful and lovely with her hair pulled up and her arms circling her head, and all the stress in my bones is dissipating as I follow her across the floor, thinking there's no way I haven't known her forever.

I didn't tell any of that in order but all if it happened in the last two weeks, the days tumbling into and out of each other, a science project and papers to grade and a dog to get groomed and phone calls from my father, mostly good, in the midst of all of it.

Tonight I am calmer than I've been in months. The grief of the losses the GLBT community sustained is fading. I did what I needed--took a two hour retreat and burned my incense and prayed the anger and bitterness away, gathered with friends who lit candles and signed cards for people who did what they could, went to a protest in Fargo and felt the surge of warmth and joy among so many like-minded people, many of them straight supporters. The joy of the big wins has softened, too, and I'm back to feeling cautiously hopeful about the state of the world in general.

And I am thinking now of how far S. has come, despite her recent outburst, and how even this one step forward, two steps back progress is incredible. In the last week she's faced the heartbreak of a boy who doesn't like her back and the anger of having to hear her friends casually use the word rape as in "That test raped me" and not have to face the ugliness of what that word really means. She asked them to stop; they didn't get it; she felt alone in the world, like friendship was a sham and nobody would ever understand her, including me. So she lashed out.

Immediately, she was sorry, weeping, going through the consequences without any prompting--one page about what she'd do differently next time, another page of apology, the computer handed over for the week. Tonight she talked with her therapist about it and assured me on the drive home that she's back on track, back in control.

I have felt a little out of control myself--drank a little too much at one of our gatherings (the non-political one), told some stories I didn't really need to repeat, didn't pay as much attention as I should have to S., struggled each morning to finish the prep for the day's meetings, suddenly no more than an hour ahead of my own calendar, if that. Something about the cold settling in, our bodies going stiff against it, makes it hard to feel in control.

What has saved S. and I from total disaster has been the long drives (well, therapy, too, but mostly the long drives). We drive every other week 1 1/2 hours for her therapy. We drove this weekend to the protest two hours away. We've started driving occasionally to the closest Unitarian Universalist church about an hour away, a small gathering, rotating leaders. It's lovely and moving and thoughtful and the people are warm. I wish it were closer, but it's something, and this weekend, S. insisted on going, even though we had partied and protested over the weekend and, frankly, couldn't afford the time.

"Driving makes me feel quiet inside," she said on the ride home on Sunday, and again tonight, as we watched the sky go gray-blue and the clouds lengthen and imagined the next snowfall forming, invisible but also forseeable--and because of both the mystery and circularity of storms, and also because they are so beautiful, we can go on.

Wednesday, November 05, 2008

And the dust settles

Four anti-gay amendments in one night. We're still waiting for a recount on Prop 8, but it doesn't look good. After I posted my last blog, I was up another three or so hours, answering facebook messages, text messages, e-mails. People were ecstatic--and also depressed. It was hard to know what to feel.

On the one hand, I felt guilty for not feeling elated--fully, totally, purely. On the other hand, I felt guilty for feeling as happy as I did. It was surreal, actually.

What does it tell us, as a nation, that we can "vote for change" while at the same time voting against basic civil rights?

Yes, there will be some legal battles, the seeds of which have already begun. But some of us are tired of living in fear and worry that our children could be taken from us, that we have to rely on the whims of voters to determine whether or not our relationships "count."

I can't help but think of what would have happened if I lived in Arkansas and the adoption had not yet finalized. Would S. have been taken from me if I was openly queer, even if single? What if I simply chose to go back into the closet, not mention my sexual orientation to anyone--then would I have been allowed to keep her?

We don't know for a fact how many families are actually living now in fear of losing foster children they'd hoped to adopt in Arkansas, and I would venture to guess that we will never hear their stories. Social workers might look the other way; parents might crawl into their closets and stay there, claim to be "roommates only."

But what kind of family can be healthy if its members cannot live openly?

This morning I exchanged an e-mail with a friend in CA who had been texting me most of the night last night. I asked her how she was feeling, tried to encourage her to be hopeful even in the face of such ugly news. Yes, it's true--if Prop 8 doesn't fail in CA, of all places, then what hope is there? A federal amendment, I suggested--no, she said. Remember, even Obama thinks gay marriage should be up to the states.

But he's a good man, I argued, feeling less and less sure of myself. He could change his mind. And we have a new openly gay congressperson. Things could go our way.

And then, today, another message: it's not really up to him (or them) to change things, it's up to us. So we offer to help with the legal challenges in whatever way we can. And then--we start planting the "federal amendment" seed, start writing our letters, talking to our representatives. Most of all, we hope, pray, whatever we do, that our leaders will lead with integrity, and that our fellow voters will vote in the same way.

Be present, a friend urged a group of us a couple hours ago in another e-mail. Don't go away, either because you think everything will get fixed now or because you're too depressed to think about how to get out of this AR-AZ-FL mess.

Don't worry--none of us are going anywhere, right?

Tuesday, November 04, 2008

Obama!

This morning at 7 a.m., my daughter and I went to the polls. (In our small town, there was no line yet--we were the only ones there!). The election judges let her go in with me so she could see what it was like to fill out a ballot.

I have tried to allow S. to explore all sides of the issues that matter to her, but of course she's been influenced by me. We don't agree on everything, but we agree on much more than we did when she came to me, and we were both rooting for the same candidates and issues.

We were uncharacteristically silent as I drove her to school. "I hope he wins," she whispered as she got out of the car.

"Me too."

---

The campus was alive with messages to vote Democratic, to vote for change. I feel lucky to work where I work.

This afternoon, we had an appointment in a town two hours away. Usually I spend election day door knocking and phone calling and driving people to the polls, but this year I spent it driving to and from our appointment. It felt strange, and when I remarked on this to a relative on the phone, S. said, "Mom, you have a DAUGHTER now." Of course I would have included her in the effort if we'd had the time--but we didn't. She had a point; my life is totally different now.

On the drive home, we continued to listen to NPR in silence. I was so nervous. The first good news was that Hagen had beat Dole, and that PA had gone for Obama. I was shouting, high fiving S, who was threatening to force me to pull over if I didn't stop. Five more states going Democratic in house and senate races. Ecstatic.

Then we got the first call--my aunt who raised me (whom S. calls "yiayia," or grandma in Greek), announcing that CNN and MSNBC had called both Ohio and Michigan. More shouting. I started to cry. I couldn't believe it was happening. (NPR followed soon after). Then S's godmother, who voted for the first time this year, having just finally become a U.S. citizen, called, and when I asked her how it felt to have voted, she choked up. Then my father--tired from his cancer treatments, he was shouting wildly, happy about politics for the first time in years.

We went immediately to a friend's home and watched the returns on T.V. (we don't have one at home). When Obama actually won, S. made the rounds, hugging and kissing everyone. We both wept, watching the crowds on T.V. gather and hug each other. Then my aunt called, in tears. "I wish your mom and aunt were here to witness this," she said, and I felt my heart swell, remembering how deeply they had believed in the Democratic party and liberal ideals, how important political involvement was to them. I think they would have been proud of me for passing on those ideals to S.

Back at home, we listened to Obama's speech on NPR. More crying. Lots of text messages from former and current students and other friends. So much joy.

---

In 1992, I worked my ass off for Clinton's campaign as a college student, and our College Democrats rented out a bar in town for what we hoped would be our victory party. The election season had been hard for me. I'd been harassed by some closed-minded people throughout the entire election period--Feminazi had been spraypainted outside my window, vulgar images of gay sex and aborted fetuses pasted to my dorm room door--so the victory felt personal, like Clinton could somehow shut these nutty, hateful people up.

In a way, that did happen, and things were good for a long time. Unlike some of my recent students, I had a good job out of college, and graduated without too much debt. Graduate school a couple years later made sense, even though at the time it wasn't clear what kind of job opportunities would follow. I am lucky, I know, to be well employed at a job I love, especially in this economy.

There were, of course, bad times, too. I was in Cincinnati when an anti-gay city initiative passed there. I didn't agree with many of Clinton's decisions, but I also didn't cringe, as I have for the last eight years, every time I heard our president talking on the radio.

Tonight, I feel a little like I did the night Clinton won the first time. I'm sober, though, and also more cognizant of the fact that Obama's win isn't going to solve all our nation's problems. But I also feel hopeful.

Some friends stopped by from a much wilder party that I'd decided not to attend, wanting instead to be with people who would watch more quietly, and with families with kids S. knew well. My friends were going out to the bar to celebrate, but I couldn't join them--I think I'm feeling too overwhelmed to do so. I want instead to hold some kind of vigil--to be silent and full of wonder right now--but also, to get the rest of the news.

Now that S. is in bed, I've had time to surf the internet. Everything isn't good--our state DFL Senate and House candidates are losing at the moment, though the Senate race remains close. California's Proposition 8 is passing, though the more urban areas have not been counted yet, so there's still hope--I can't bear the thought of those GLBT couples having their marriage licenses revoked. There are similar initiatives in two other states, and in a third, an initiative to disallow GLBT couples to adopt. S. was especially upset about this one--she didn't want to go to bed without getting the results. But none of these results are final yet, and it's nearing 12:30 here, so I'll probably get to bed before I know the results for sure.

---

At the party tonight, a friend's three year old kept asking, over and over, when Obama was going to arrive at the party. It was so sweet; she truly believed he would walk through the door. I think he makes a lot of us feel that way--as if he's somehow accessible, that we know him in a way we haven't known many others.

---

Tonight when I put S. to bed, she asked me to sing her a political song. There were, of course, lots of options, but I chose "Don't Stop Thinking About Tomorrow," the hallmark song of Clinton's first campaign. She was asleep by the time I got to the last line of the chorus (which is all I really know--and maybe all there is to the song, anyway?)--

Yesterday's gone, yesterday's gone!